Are IRS Mail Audits Really Something to Worry About?

Most people think IRS audits are probably very bad.

Maybe you’ll have to sit in a cold, dark room with a suited and well-starched IRS agent who asks cutting — and maybe confusing — questions about your tax return and your income. All to prove you are a tax cheat.

Good news. For most people, this is far from reality. The IRS does 70% of audits by mail.

But just because you get an IRS audit letter instead of an IRS agent at your door, the outcome may not be much different than a face-to-face audit with an IRS agent. In fact, in 2016, the IRS made a change to the return in 89% of all mail audits.

The average amount of additional tax owed in an audit is over $6,500, not including penalties and interest.

Face-to-face audits have only a slightly higher change rate: 92%. But because many face-to-face audits involve higher-income and business returns, the average additional tax owed is almost 10 times higher than in mail audits.

So, should you worry about your mail audit? Yes and no.

Don’t worry about dealing with the IRS in person

Most of the time, when the IRS starts a mail audit, the IRS will ask you to explain or verify something simple on your return, such as:

  • Income you didn’t report that the IRS knows about (like leaving off Form 1099 income)
  • Filing status
  • Dependents
  • Itemized deductions
  • Eligibility for credits

Just make sure to respond the right way

If you’re audited by mail, you’ll need to respond to the IRS by mail with a complete written explanation. That’s not nearly as intimidating as answering questions in an interview with an IRS agent, like in face-to-face IRS audits.

In most mail audits, the IRS is asking you to:

  • Provide receipts or documents to prove an item the IRS is questioning on your return.
  • Explain your circumstances.

If you provide these by the deadline on your mail audit notice, you’ll generally end up OK. And even if you don’t have receipts, your explanation may be enough to sway the IRS in your favor.

And remember, if you’re worried about going to jail for tax evasion, take heart. Most tax evasion cases start with more complex face-to-face audits. Mail audits shouldn’t cause the same anxiety as dealing directly with the IRS.

Worry about a mail audit if you don’t respond to the IRS completely and by the deadline

Many people wonder what happens if they:

  • Don’t respond at all.
  • Send an incomplete response.
  • Respond late.
  • Send multiple letters to the IRS.
  • Aren’t sure whether they’re responding correctly.

This is where it helps to know how the IRS works.

The IRS doesn’t assign your mail audit to one person. So, one IRS employee won’t be contacting you to handle the case and follow up. In fact, if you don’t respond, respond late, or respond incompletely, the IRS will likely just disallow the items it’s questioning on your return and send you a tax bill – plus penalties and interest.

Multiple responses confuse the IRS. That’s because a central processing center must combine all your letters to understand your position. But the IRS processes millions of taxpayer responses to audits and notices. If the IRS doesn’t properly associate all your letters, you could get a confusing notice that shows the IRS hasn’t incorporated one or more of your responses in its decision about your mail audit.

Taxpayers who aren’t totally sure how to respond often find the help of a professional who has experience in IRS mail audits and understands how to navigate the IRS and deal with the IRS for them.

How long it takes to resolve a mail audit: three months to more than a year

If you respond on time with one complete letter that explains your situation and provides documentation, you’ll get the best result in the quickest time. A mail audit can conclude in about three months if you follow this rule.

If you don’t, mail audits can stretch out for a year or more. If the IRS tax examiner decides that you owe more taxes, and even penalties, you still have some options. You can agree or ask the IRS Appeals Office to review your case.

IRS Appeals is not intimidating; they look at your case and any new information you have and will give you an independent analysis. Taxpayers often favor this second look.

If you end up owing more taxes, you don’t have to pay immediately

You can set up payment arrangements with the IRS, from extensions to monthly payment plans. And if you have a financial hardship, the IRS offers other arrangements that allow you to defer payment or settle.

Rest easy. And if you want to rest easier, give your mail audit to an experienced tax pro who can handle it end to end. Learn about H&R Block’s Tax Audit & Notice Services. Or make an appointment for a free consultation with a local tax professional by calling 855-536-6504 or finding a local tax pro.

Related Topics

Related Resources

IRS Notice CP63 – The IRS is Holding Your Tax Refund

Learn more about notice CP63, why you received it, and how to handle an IRS CP63 notice with help from the tax experts at H&R Block.

IRS Letter 2269C – Delinquent Tax Return/Insufficient Response

Learn more about letter 2269C, why you received it, and how to handle an IRS 2269C letter with help from the tax experts at H&R Block.

IRS Notice CP163 – Reminder of Overdue Taxes

Learn more about notice CP163 and how to handle an IRS tax bill for your business with help from the tax experts at H&R Block.

Tax Dictionary – IRS Manager Conference

Get the facts about IRS manager conferences, which may allow you and the IRS to come to an agreement, but remember to protect your appeal rights.