Question

I have a question about IRA withdraw penalties. If I withdrew Roth IRA funds of amounts I contributed four years ago, why am I being charged IRA withdraw penalties now?

Answer

You must have a Roth IRA for five years before you can take a qualified distribution. It doesn’t have to be the same Roth IRA as the one you’re withdrawing from.

The five-year period starts on Jan. 1 of the first tax year you opened and funded a Roth IRA. It ends five years later on Dec. 31. This is a lifetime qualification. So, after you meet the holding-period requirement once for the first Roth IRA you own:

  • You’ll have met the holding periods for all Roth IRAs you own.
  • Regarding IRA withdraw penalties, you can take out earnings tax-free and penalty-free after age 59 1/2 — or earlier if you qualify for a Form 5329 exception.

Related Topics

Related Resources

Reporting Rental Income on Tax Return

Renting property comes with extra tax reporting. Learn what you need to know about reporting rental income on your tax return from the experts at H&R Block.

Are Your Social Security Benefits Taxable?

Are Social Security benefits considered taxable income? Learn more about Social Security taxability and how it relates to retirement income at H&R Block.

Holding Period

What is a holding period? Learn more about an investment holding period and get tax answers at H&R Block.

Filing a Dependent’s Tax Return

Do you have a dependent child who’s wondering how to file a dependent tax return? Learn more about dependent tax filing with the experts at H&R Block.